a San Diego street filled with lots of traffic under a blue sky
Some of the links in this post are affiliate links. This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. All opinions remain my own.

Should I Rent a Car in San Diego? Getting Around San Diego in 2024


You’ve come to the right place! As someone who’s been writing about this beautiful city for a couple of years, I’ve got some insider tips to share.

San Diego, with its endless sunshine, gorgeous beaches, and laid-back vibe, is a traveler’s dream.

But when it comes to navigating this sprawling city, the big question often is: Should you rent a car? It’s a decision that can really shape your experience here.

white Volkswagen Beetle on road at daytime

When booking your San Diego car rental online, I recommend and use Discover Cars. They search and compare many car rental companies, so you get the best deal — and have FREE cancellation up to 48 hours before your rental.

In this post, I’ll dive into the nitty-gritty of getting around in San Diego. From the freedom of driving along the coast with your own set of wheels to the adventures of exploring the city’s neighborhoods without the hassle of parking, I’ve covered it all.

So, buckle up as we explore the pros and cons of renting a car in San Diego, along with some handy alternatives.

Trust me, with a few years of San Diego stories under my belt, I’ve got some insights that just might make your trip even more unforgettable!

Understanding San Diego’s Layout and Attractions

Before you decide on renting a car, let’s take a little virtual tour of this gorgeous city’s layout and its must-see spots.

San Diego isn’t your typical grid-like city. It’s more like a collection of unique neighborhoods, each with its own vibe and attractions.

Picture this: to the north, you’ve got the laid-back beach towns like La Jolla, where the waves seem to whisper your name. Head south, and you’ll find yourself in the bustling Downtown, where the Gaslamp Quarter always promises a good time.

Now, let’s talk about getting around. San Diego is pretty spread out. Sure, you’ve got the city center, but many of the gems are scattered along the coast and inland. Take the San Diego Zoo, nestled in the vast Balboa Park. It’s a world of its own! And if you’re a beach lover, places like Coronado Beach or the cliffs of Torrey Pines are not just around the corner.

But here’s the thing: San Diego’s charm lies in its diversity. One moment you’re in the urban heart, and the next, you could be sipping a local brew in the North Park neighborhood, known for its craft beer scene. Or maybe you’re watching the sunset in Ocean Beach, where the laid-back lifestyle is almost palpable.

Transportation can be a bit of a puzzle here. The trolley system is great for certain areas, especially if you’re sticking to downtown or heading to Tijuana for a quick adventure. But if your heart is set on exploring those picturesque, out-of-the-way spots, public transport might leave you wishing for more.

So, as you’re pondering over that car rental, think about what you want from your San Diego adventure. Are you here for the urban hustle and bustle, or are you itching to explore every hidden beach and cliffside trail? San Diego’s layout and attractions offer a world of possibilities, each with its own set of wheels in mind.

a person flying a kite on top of a hill near the ocean
Enjoy great views while golfing at the Torrey Pines Golf Course in La Jolla.

Pros of Renting a Car in San Diego

There are some undeniable perks to having your own set of wheels in San Diego.

First off, freedom is the name of the game. With a car at your disposal, you’re the master of your itinerary. Fancy a spontaneous trip to La Jolla for some sea lion spotting? Or what about a sunset drive to Mount Soledad for breathtaking views? That’s the beauty of having a car – spontaneity becomes your travel buddy.

Then there’s the convenience factor. Let’s be real, lugging beach gear, shopping bags, or tired kiddos on public transport isn’t anyone’s idea of fun. A car gives you the luxury of space and comfort, turning what could be a tiring journey into a relaxed cruise with your favorite tunes.

San Diego’s size plays a big role too. It’s a sprawling city, and some of the best spots are, well, not exactly next door to each other. Want to compare the vibes between the Gaslamp Quarter and the chill surf spots in Pacific Beach? Or maybe you’re keen to explore the vineyards in Temecula, just a drive away. A car makes these transitions seamless.

And let’s talk about those hidden gems. Sure, the major attractions are fantastic, but San Diego is full of off-the-beaten-path spots that public transport doesn’t always reach. Hidden beaches, quaint little cafes tucked away in the hills, scenic drives along the coast – these treasures become accessible with a car.

Flexibility with family and group travel is another big plus. Coordinating schedules and routes with a group can be like solving a complex puzzle. A car simplifies this, letting you all travel together, making memories from the moment you buckle up.

La Jolla Cove
La Jolla Cove is famous for its sea lion and seal populations.

Tips for Renting a Car in San Diego

Decided to go for a car rental in San Diego? Awesome choice! Here are some friendly tips to make sure your car rental experience is as smooth as the Pacific Coast Highway.

First things first, book your car in advance. Especially during peak seasons, like summer or major holidays, rental cars can get snapped up faster than a good wave at La Jolla. Using websites like Discover Cars can be a lifesaver. They compare deals from various rental companies, so you can snag the best deal without having to search a dozen sites.

When picking your car, think about what you need. If you’re planning to surf or camp, you might want something with a bit more space. But if you’re just cruising around the city, a smaller car can be easier for parking and navigating through traffic. Convertibles are popular for that classic California vibe, but remember, they usually come with a higher price tag.

Insurance is super important. Make sure you understand what’s covered. Sometimes your credit card or travel insurance already has you covered, so check that out before you pay extra at the rental desk.

Be prepared for parking. In popular areas like Downtown or near the beaches, parking can be a bit of a treasure hunt. Apps like Parkopedia can be real lifesavers, showing you nearby parking spots and their costs.

Familiarize yourself with local driving laws. For instance, California is strict on no phone use while driving. And remember, Americans drive on the right side of the road – crucial for those visiting from countries where it’s the other way around!

Lastly, keep an eye on the gas tank. Gas stations can be sparse in more remote areas, and you don’t want to be stuck on the side of the road in the beautiful yet isolated parts of San Diego County.

Renting a car in San Diego can truly enhance your trip, giving you the freedom to explore this stunning city at your own pace.

Gaslamp Quarter
Gaslamp Quarter is renowned for its rich Victorian architecture and lively nightlife

Cons of Renting a Car in San Diego

Alright, let’s flip the coin and chat about the other side of renting a car in San Diego. It’s not all sunshine and smooth drives; there are a few bumps on the road to consider.

First up, the cost can be a bit of a shocker. We’re not just talking about the rental fee here. Add in the insurance, the gas money (and let’s be honest, gas prices can be like a roller coaster ride), and those sneaky parking fees that can add up faster than you can say “beach day.” It’s like every time you park, your wallet gets a little lighter.

Speaking of parking, finding a spot can be like a competitive sport in popular areas like Downtown or near the beaches on a sunny day. You might find yourself circling the block, wishing for a parking fairy to magically appear. And when you do find a spot, the parking meters and time limits can be a hassle, especially if you’re trying to relax and enjoy your day.

Then there’s the traffic. Oh, the traffic! During peak hours, the roads can get as jam-packed as a can of sardines. If you’re not used to driving in busy city traffic, it can be a bit nerve-wracking. Plus, it eats into your precious vacation time. You came to see the sights, not the bumper of the car in front of you!

Environmental concerns are also worth mentioning. We all know cars aren’t exactly friends of the environment. If you’re someone who tries to keep their carbon footprint small, renting a car might not sit well with your green heart.

And let’s not forget, San Diego has some pretty decent public transportation options. The trolley system, for instance, covers a lot of the main attractions. It’s not perfect, but it’s a more budget-friendly and eco-conscious choice.

cars parked on the side of the road during daytime
Known for its authentic Italian restaurants, bustling farmers’ market, and quaint cafes, Little Italy combines old-world charm with modern urban living, making it a favorite for both locals and visitors.

Alternatives to Renting a Car

So, you’re thinking twice about renting a car in San Diego? No worries, there are plenty of other ways to get around this beautiful city.

Let’s dive into some alternatives that might just make your trip even more enjoyable.

First off, San Diego’s public transportation is pretty solid. The trolley system, for instance, is a great way to hop between major spots like Downtown, Old Town, and even the Mexican border. It’s affordable, and you get to skip the hassle of parking and traffic. Plus, riding the trolley is an experience in itself – it’s like a mini tour of the city!

Then there’s the good old biking and scootering around. San Diego is blessed with some seriously scenic bike paths, especially along the coast. Renting a bike or an electric scooter can be a fun and active way to explore. Imagine cruising along the waterfront with the ocean breeze in your hair – sounds pretty great, right?

Ridesharing apps like Uber and Lyft are super convenient too. They’re just a tap away on your phone, and you can go from A to B without the stress of driving and parking. Plus, you might get some cool local tips from your driver – it’s like having a mini tour guide!

If you’re sticking to the downtown area, walking is a fantastic option. Places like the Gaslamp Quarter, Little Italy, and the waterfront are best experienced on foot. You’ll stumble upon charming cafes, quirky shops, and all sorts of hidden gems that you might miss if you’re zooming by in a car.

And hey, if you’re feeling adventurous, how about a ferry ride to Coronado Island? It’s a unique way to travel and offers some stunning views of the city skyline. Once you’re there, Coronado is super walkable and just oozes charm.

So, even without a car, you’ve got a bunch of options to see the best of San Diego. Each mode of transport has its own charm and lets you experience the city from a different perspective. It’s all about what suits your vibe and your travel plans!

Should I Rent a Car in San Diego: FAQ

Spanish Village Art Center
Visit the Spanish Village Art Center midweek to avoid crowds and see artists at work. It’s a perfect spot to find unique, handcrafted souvenirs and engage with San Diego’s creative community.

Is San Diego a walkable city?

San Diego’s walkability really depends on where you are.

Downtown San Diego is super walkable. Places like the Gaslamp Quarter, Little Italy, and the Embarcadero are perfect for strolling around. You’ll find loads of cafes, shops, and attractions within easy walking distance.

But here’s the thing: San Diego is pretty spread out. If you want to explore beyond downtown, like hitting up the beaches or checking out neighborhoods like North Park, walking won’t cut it.

So, while parts of San Diego are a walker’s paradise, you’ll need wheels to fully experience everything this gorgeous city offers.

Is it safe to walk around San Diego at night?

Walking around San Diego at night is generally safe, especially in popular areas like the Gaslamp Quarter, Little Italy, and along the waterfront. These spots are usually buzzing with people and have a lively vibe.

However, like any city, it’s smart to stay aware of your surroundings. Stick to well-lit and busier streets, and maybe avoid wandering too far off the beaten path late at night.

Each neighborhood has its own character, so just keep your wits about you, and you’ll be fine.

Is San Diego easy to drive in?

Driving in San Diego is pretty straightforward, especially if you’re used to driving in other U.S. cities. The roads are well-maintained and signage is clear, which makes navigating a breeze.

However, like any major city, traffic can be a challenge during rush hours. Morning and late afternoon can get pretty congested, especially on the freeways.

Also, parking in popular areas like Downtown or near the beaches can be a bit of a hunt.

But overall, if you’re comfortable behind the wheel and can handle the occasional traffic jam, you’ll find driving in San Diego to be a pretty smooth experience.

Segway tours in San Diego
A Segway tour is definitely worth it if you’re looking for a fun, efficient way to explore a new area, and you’re comfortable with riding a Segway.

Is Uber expensive in San Diego?

Using Uber in San Diego is generally considered to be reasonably priced, especially when compared to the costs of renting a car and paying for parking.

However, prices can vary depending on the time of day and demand. During peak hours or special events, you might encounter surge pricing, which can make the fare higher.

But for the most part, Uber offers a convenient and budget-friendly alternative, especially for shorter trips around the city or when you’re heading out for a night and don’t want to worry about parking. It’s a great option for those times when you need a quick and easy ride.

Is parking difficult in San Diego?

Parking in San Diego can be a bit of a mixed bag.

In popular areas like Downtown, the Gaslamp Quarter, or near the beaches, finding a parking spot can be quite a challenge, especially during peak times or sunny weekends. These spots are in high demand, and you might find yourself circling around a bit. However, there are plenty of parking garages and lots, though they can get pricey.

In other parts of the city, parking is much easier and often free.

So, it really depends on where you’re going. Just be prepared for a bit of a hunt in the hotspots!

Does San Diego have free parking?

Yes, San Diego does have free parking, but it’s a bit like finding a hidden treasure. In many residential areas and some parts of the city, you can find street parking that’s free. However, these spots can be a bit of a rarity, especially in busy areas like Downtown or near popular beaches.

It’s always a good idea to check the parking signs for any time restrictions or permit requirements.

On Sundays and public holidays, you’ll also find that metered parking is free in many areas.

So, while free parking exists, it’s all about being in the right place at the right time!

brown dome building
The Botanical Building is an iconic part of Balboa Park. It’s worth seeing on the outside even if you don’t venture inside.

Final Thoughts: Should I Rent a Car in San Diego

Alright, we’ve cruised through the ins and outs of whether to rent a car in San Diego. After writing about this sun-kissed city for a couple of years, I’ve seen how this decision can really shape your experience.

Here’s the deal: San Diego is a diverse and sprawling city. If you’re the type who loves the freedom to explore hidden beaches, scenic drives, and distant attractions at your own pace, then renting a car is a no-brainer. It’s all about that flexibility and convenience, which can be a game-changer for your trip.

But, if you’re planning to stick to the bustling downtown areas or are on a tight budget, skipping the rental might be your best bet. Embrace the local vibe by hopping on a trolley, renting a bike, or just walking through the vibrant neighborhoods. Plus, you’ll be doing your bit for the environment.

Every traveler’s needs are different, and San Diego offers options for all. Whether you choose to drive, ride, or walk, this city won’t disappoint. It’s packed with adventures, stunning views, and unforgettable experiences.

So, take these tips, weigh your options, and get ready for an amazing time in San Diego!

Additional San Diego Travel Blogs

Renting a Car in San Diego: What You Need to Know

Best Time to Visit San Diego California [Month by Month Guide]

San Diego California Map: Where is San Diego Located?